Gullwing Alternative: 1958 Mercedes-Benz 190SL

Disclosure: This site may receive compensation from some link clicks and purchases.

Less sporty than luxurious, the 190SL was Mercedes’ answer to Max Hoffman’s suggestion that an alternative to the expensive, race-bred 300SL would be welcome in the American market. A prototype of the new car was plying the roads by 1954, but the production version wouldn’t be ready until 1955. With its stylish roadster-only body style, 104-hp four-cylinder engine, and posh interior, the 190SL sold almost 26,000 copies through 1963. It wasn’t fast, but it made its occupants look marvelous, and that was good enough. Today’s example requires TLC – though exactly what type/nature/extent other than its obvious cosmetic needs is not revealed – but it does drive. The new owner can retrieve it from La Habra, California.

The “baby” SL came from the factory with a 1.9-liter four-cylinder overhead cam engine breathing through dual twin-choke Solex carburetors – a departure from 300SL’s stout, powerful, fuel-injected six. US-delivery cars had a compression ratio of 8.5:1. Performance was middling: the 2550 lb car (saturated with safety features) managed zero to sixty in about 14.5 seconds. Top speed was about 107 mph. A common swap to Weber carburetors provides a couple more horsepower, but the motor was built to run off Solexes. Fortunately, Mercedes improved its old swing-axle rear suspension by limiting travel and dropping the car’s center of gravity. Handling improved immensely. The gearbox from the factory was a four-speed manual; this seller indicates that his car is an automatic. I doubt that’s true, but owners have been known to swap to a later Fintail automatic – though not without considerable fabrication.

The interior is generously appointed, with big, easy-to-read gauges, plush seating, and liberal trim. One of my favorite features of the 190SL is the clock inset into the glovebox lid; many cars both before and after this model feature glovebox clocks, but for some reason its presence in this nifty roadster strikes the right chord. A Blaupunkt radio was standard.

Mercedes would supply a hardtop, a soft top, or both to buyers. This car has both tops. Obviously, someone has performed bodywork on the nose and the tail, and the paint is shot. There’s no mention of rust. The trunk lock is missing, but the remainder of the exterior trim is in adequate condition. Between this seller and the car’s prior owner, 25 years of records are available. This car is listed here on facebook Marketplace for $65,000, which might seem eyepopping for a project car, but that’s about what 190SLs in tatty condition sell for these days. Restored examples can easily break through the $200k level, and middling cars will cost north of $100k. I’d love to give this car a berth in my garage, and I were so lucky, I would attend to reliability and leave it alone after that. What would you do with this baby SL?

Auctions Ending Soon

Comments

  1. 8banger 8bangerMember

    While I DO love our ’83 380 SL (converted to a double-roller TC) in our garage, I, like you, Michelle, would make space for this one if I could…

    Like 6
  2. LMK

    Gone already….

    Like 1
  3. chrlsful

    each Spring I keep heads up to see the older Black fella in the snap brim bring out his white twine of this model.

    He usually has the hrd top off, driving w/a big smile. 40 yrs ago I wrked onan estate (Sherborn, MA) w/one of these in a barn. Never more than a slight dust on it. My employer told me he brought it back from the Continent after using it to tour right out of the dealer over there (he musta been in his 20s then).

    Been following the model here (shown 280, 350, 450 and 500 recently). A bit of a class of its own, no? Great Itilnate styling. I’d never call it a baby SL. A car in its own right ! At least till the late 80s. Some stutter-steps there by the oldest continuous car builder but seems to be getting back on track. Let’s C what they can do in this model w/o AMG… consider them coach builders ofa sort, ’25 and beyond…

    Like 1
  4. jwaltb

    Secretary’s car then, secretary’s car now..

    Like 2
  5. Fox owner

    65K, that’s a hard no, no matter what it’s worth restored.

    Like 2
  6. Scotty GilbertsonStaff

    Dang, I passed on a perfect one a little over 20 years ago for $30,000, it’s hard to believe how much they’re worth now. It didn’t have a hardtop, though, so maybe that’s why it was so “cheap.”

    Like 2
  7. Frank BarrettMember

    One of the most over-rated cars that Daimler-Benz ever built. Three-main bearing crank. Troublesome carbs. No guts. Hard to work on. Rust-prone. Expensive to restore properly. They look good, but it’s really just a poser’s car, and way over-priced.

    Like 6
    • HoosMember

      My uncle has had his since he was in college in 1968. It was his everyday driver until 1974 when he got a company car. He has had little trouble with it for the last 57 years. He did rebuild the carbs once, about 20 years ago, and he put a clutch in around 2008. It has well over 300K on the drivetrain, with no major repairs. He’s been the only person to work on it since he bought it, except for a professional repaint.

      Like 0
  8. John Grant

    I agree with Frank, “just a posers car”.
    I raced one these with my 58 TR3 in 1961
    And passed him and left him in the dust.
    I also drove his 190sl and it handled
    Like a 58 Cadillac.

    Like 3

Leave A Comment

RULES: No profanity, politics, or personal attacks.

Become a member to add images to your comments.

*

Get new comment updates via email. Or subscribe without commenting.

Barn Finds