57k Original Miles: 1963 Oldsmobile Starfire

We’re no strangers to low-mile claims at Barn Finds, and some must be taken at face value. Such is the case with this 1963 Oldsmobile Starfire. The seller believes that the odometer reading of 57,000 miles is genuine, based on the overall condition. Scrutinizing the listing images supports this, but there’s nothing like documentary evidence to remove lingering doubts. I must say a big thank you to Barn Finder Curvette for spotting the Starfire listed here on eBay in Englewood, Colorado. The seller set their BIN at $39,900 with the option to make an offer.

Released in 1961, the First Generation Starfire was initially Convertible-only territory. Oldsmobile introduced a Hardtop in 1962, and sales boomed as a result. This Hardtop was built in 1963 and ordered by its first owner in Regal Red. The appearance is first-rate, adding weight to the mileage claim. The paint reflects its surroundings like a mirror, and the panels are laser-straight. If this classic is a genuine low-mile survivor, it has obviously led a sheltered existence and been somebody’s pride and joy. I can’t spot any rust, nor any issues with the glass or chrome. The company’s decision to adorn the exterior with brushed aluminum trim enhances the luxury feel, and the car’s trim appears virtually faultless. One appealing feature is the spinner hubcaps, giving this Starfire a sense of purpose.

The horsepower race was in full swing in the 1960s, and Oldsmobile delivered with the 1963 Starfire. Its 394ci V8 sends an impressive 345hp and 440 ft/lbs of torque to the rear wheels via a three-speed automatic transmission. In keeping with the car’s luxury leanings, power-assisted steering and brakes were standard in 1963. The seller states they have no documentary evidence supporting their mileage claim and bases it on the vehicle’s overall presentation. Their use of the word “excellent” in the listing suggests that this Starfire is a turnkey proposition with no mechanical shortcomings.

Air conditioning, power windows, a console, a factory tachometer, leather upholstery, and a Wonderbar radio. Those features combine to provide a comfortable motoring experience. The seller confirms that the A/C is a retrofit system, but the remaining features are original. As with the exterior, there is nothing inside this Starfire deserving criticism. The leather looks supple and inviting, the carpet is spotless, and the painted surfaces are excellent. There is bright trim on the dashboard and door cards that mimics the exterior, and it is free from dings and marks. The interior is almost dazzlingly bright, but it still feels classy and luxurious.

The introduction of the Starfire Hardtop in 1962 was a stellar move by Oldsmobile. A sales tally of 7,149 Convertibles represented a significant increase over the previous year’s 1,500 cars, but 34,839 buyers selected the Hardtop. The company came crashing to Earth in 1963, with that figure dropping to 21,489. While researching this story, I found a prior listing for this car from October 2024. The car sold on that occasion for $26,750, which is considerably less than the current BIN. Do you believe that the increase is justified, or do you have a lower price in mind?